Project Big Picture a ‘disaster’ for race equality in football
The Premier League’s ‘Project Big Picture’ would represent a huge setback for race equality in the game, according to one leading expert. Liverpool-based Emy Onuora , 55, says Project Big Picture - which was roundly rejected at a meeting of the 20 clubs in England's top flight on Wednesday - would have been deeply unhelpful when it comes to getting more black coaches employed in the sport.
Emy Onuora is the author of best-selling book Pitch Black: The Story of Black British Footballers. The brother of former Gillingham striker Iffy Onuora, Emy he’s also lectured extensively on issues of race and sport within higher education. Emy, speaking ahead of a Black History Month event at Liverpool Hope University, said: “I can’t see anything good coming from Project Big Picture, on any level. I understand that the EFL clubs are in a tricky situation financially, but accepting Project Big Picture would have been accepting short term gain for long term pain. In terms of race equality, it would have been an utter disaster.”
As well as a £250m bailout package for EFL clubs, the defeated - for now - Project Big Picture also proposed handing more powers to the so-called 'big six' Premier League clubs.
Emy added: “Shifting such powers to a group of powerful, rich men would pose huge difficulties for people campaigning for greater diversity and equality in football. They’d have a much tougher time getting initiatives through and also just to get their voices heard in order to make the game far more diverse. Football is full of cronyism and nepotism at the best of times. This will just exacerbate the situation. There’s not a great deal of accountability within the game as it is. If you reduce this accountability and scrutiny further it could be hugely damaging."
Emy points to the recent strides made in raising awareness about race equality in football through the Black Lives Matter movement and the Premier League’s ‘No Room For Racism’ initiative. "I’m not sure how anyone can fail to see the disastrous consequences should Project Big Picture ever be implemented. Rejecting Project Big Picture is imperative for the integrity of the game and I’m pleased it has been defeated in its current form.”
But he supports the view of QPR’s Director of Football Les Ferdinand in warning there’s a danger that taking the knee becomes something of an empty gesture.
Emy, based in Aigburth, south Liverpool, adds: “I’m heartened by the events that have taken place in recent months. It’s been nothing short of seismic. But we always have to ask - what happens next? What needs to change? This is the bit that hasn’t quite materialised yet.
“And there’s a danger that the Black Lives Matter symbol has, in some respects, been commodified and commercialised to the point where it’s a little bit meaningless.
“It’s a sticking plaster rather than the fundamental change that needs to happen.”
Fundamental change in the way coaches are recruited
Emy says: “For me, it’s all about power at the top of the game.
“Black footballers represent a quarter to a third of all footballers but the key decision makers are a handful of rich white owners - and for the most part rich, powerful men.
“That means black footballers are allowed to populate academies, play at professional level, and play through the age groups at national level.
“But as soon as they retire they’re not allowed to continue to forge a career in the game because all the coaching positions, as well as some of the senior administrative roles, are carved up and handed to white guys.
“There needs to be fundamental change in the way coaches are recruited, in the way candidates for administrative roles are selected,
“There’s not a semblance of transparency when it comes to the selection process. Jobs aren’t advertised, backroom deals are done, somebody’s friend, son or cousin is given the job.
“Any system like that will exclude black people because they’re often not part of those elite networks.”
Pitch Black: The Story of Black British Footballers
by Emy Onuora
Published in Hardcover
Publisher : Biteback Publishing; First Edition ( 21 April 2015)
Hardcover : 352 pages
ISBN-10 : 1849548145 (Hardcover)
ASIN : B00W7A23BK (Kindle)
Guide Price: £13.99 - Hardcover | £7.79 - Kindle Edition
Click to buy Hardcover edition | Kindle edition
When Paul Canoville took to the pitch for Chelsea in 1982, he was prepared for abuse. When the monkey chanting and the banana throwing started, he wasn't surprised. He wasn't prepared, however, for the abuse to be coming from his own side.
Canoville was the only member of the team whose name was booed instead of cheered, the only player whose kit wasn't sponsored. He received razor blades in the post. He took to waiting two or three hours to leave the ground after a match, fearing for his safety. So minimal was the presence of black players in the game, the few who managed to break through were subjected to the most graphic abuse from all sides.
Today, 30 per cent of English professional footballers are black, and amongst their number are some of the biggest heroes of the beautiful game. But just how far have we come?
With unprecedented access to current and former players ranging from Viv Anderson to Cyrille Regis to John Barnes, Emy Onuora charts the revolutionary changes that have taken place both on and off the pitch, and argues that the battleground has shifted from the stands to the board room.
In this fascinating new book, Onuora critically scrutinises the attitudes of FIFA, the FA and the media over the last half-century, and asks what is being done to combat the subtler forms of racism that undeniably persist even today. Featuring startling revelations from all levels of the footballing fraternity, Pitch Black takes a frank and controversial look at the history of the world's most popular sport and its future.
About the Author
Emy Onuora has an MA in Ethnic Studies and Race Relations from the University of Liverpool and has lectured extensively on issues of Race and Sport within higher education. He was co-editor of the Merseyside based football fanzine What's the Score and is the brother of former footballer, coach and Ethiopia national team manager, Iffy Onuora. He lives in Liverpool.
