Lammy to lead BAME review of Criminal Justice

The Prime Minister, David Cameron has asked David Lammy MP to lead a review to investigate evidence of possible bias and disproportionate sentencing of African, Caribbean and Asian defendants in the Criminal Justice System, as part of the Equality and Criminal Justice reform. David Lammy MP is to report back in spring of 2017.

The Prime Minister said, "We need to ask the difficult questions about whether the system treats people differently based on race. Charges, courts, prisons and rehabilitation to be scrutinised."

The Rt Hon David Lammy, M.P., said, "I've been working in this area for almost 2 decades and am very pleased to accept the Prime Minister's invitation to lead this comprehensive, independent review across our criminal justice system. With over a quarter of the prison population coming from BAME background the urgency is clear.

I look forward to leading a team that will evaluate what works in the UK, draw on lessons from abroad and listen to a broad range of voices from the justice system and our BAME communities."

Lord Chancellor and Justice Secretary, the Rt Hon Michael Grove MP, said: "An effective justice system depends on procedural fairness. Equality of treatment at every stage in the criminal justice process is essential. I am very pleased that David, a politician whose intellectual honesty I have long admired, and who is not afraid to confront uncomfortable truths, is pursuing this important work."

However a number of organisations oppose the review, stating that "there is a need for such a review, as a report entitled Statistics on Race and the Criminal Justice System 2012, produced by the Ministry of Justice found that almost 20% per cent of black and Asian defendants were more likely to be jailed than white defendants for similar offences. Average sentence given to an Afro-Caribbean defendant is seven times longer than that for an average white defendant.

Stop and search figures revealed a similar pattern of over representation, a black person aged ten or older in 2011/ 2012, were 6 times more likely than a white person to be stopped and searched and nearly three times more likely to be arrested.

The same report found that only 26 per cent of white criminals were handed immediate custodial sentences compared to 31 per cent for black criminals and 32 per cent for Asian criminals. Again this differential treatment can be seen in the average custodial sentence for black prisoners was 23.4 months compared to 15.9 months for white prisoners."

Institutional racism within the system

Speaking as the Chairman of the Society of Black Lawyers, the former Vice Chair of the Metropolitan Police Authority, and part time Judge, D. Peter Herbert O.B.E. said, "the figures showed 'institutional racism' within the system."'

Organisations such as the Society of Black Lawyers, Blaksox, National Black Police Association and ABPO - The Black staff association for Ministry of Justice & National Offender Management Staff plan to collectively express a view and put forward written and oral evidence of anecdotal cases and a joint position on solutions, as a way forward.